follow journalism_news at http://twitter.com



Alphason TV Stands from Go Electrical

Classic Car Insurance from Footman James

Pub Insurance from Supercover Ltd

Home Lighting from Light My Home

Wireless Headsets from Headsets4Business



rss feed
As featured on News Now
HTFP Facebook page
Email
Journalism books
 

Council jobsite has cost papers £5m say MPs

A committee of MPs has hit out at Scottish councils for moving job advertising away from newspapers and onto a purpose-built website.

The backbench Scottish Affairs Committee today published a report entitled 'Crisis in the Scottish Press' following an inquiry carried out earlier this year.

It revealed that the decision of 32 Scottish councils to launch a combined jobs portal has so far cost the newspaper industry in Scotland £5m.

The report also says a further £10m of revenue may be at risk if local authority public notices are switched over to the site.

The committee pointed out that just 32pc of the Scottish population have access to broadband - much lower than in the UK as a whole.

"Whilst it is understandable that local authorities will want to reduce costs in the current economic climate, there are concerns that advertising jobs on public sector portals only was likely to limit the field of applicants to those already in the public sector rather than the wider audience of traditional print media," said the report.

"We are concerned at suggestions of a move to publish public notices on public sector portals whilst broadband take-up remains relatively low in some areas of Scotland.

"We would ask the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities and the Scottish Executive to produce evidence that substantial parts of the population would not be excluded before removing public notices entirely from print media."

The report also said the committee "noted" the concerns that had been raised over the impact of recent job losses on the ability of the Scottish press to deliver high-quality journalism.

"It is vital that both the Scottish Executive and the UK Government ensure that the Scottish newspaper industry is not made unviable through overbearing competition from public sector advertising, and that the industry is able to adapt itself to create sustainable business models, through consolidation and mergers subject to the appropriate safeguards, whilst maintaining high quality, varied and independent journalism that reflects the Scottish identity," the report concludes.





R McGeddon (13/07/2009 14:49)
I'm sorry to say it, but if we journo's came across a local authority that paid a private business a fee for a service which it could provide more cheaply in-house, we'd be down on them like a ton of bricks...


Michael (14/07/2009 09:09)
I have to agree with R McGeddon on this one. I understand how this is frustrating for newspaper bosses but for the tax payer it's just common sense and value for money!


michael johnston (15/07/2009 09:11)
You say "commonsense" but I suspect you have not seen an economic justification of the project from either the Scottish Government or COSLA - because there isn't one available (although the First Minister has agreed to commission a report). The whole point is this scheme isn't value for money. It's old fashioned state intervention. And it excludes a very substantial proportion of the Scottish population that either cannot or don't want to access broadband. The portal initiative has sucked in millions of taxpayers funds - your and my money - already without any proper control and checks at a time when there is a cost effective solution available in the commercial sector. Senior HR managers across Scottish local government admit - albeit privately - that the scheme isn't delivering. Perhaps we journos shouldn't always take the official comments, however upbeat, of a faceless civil servant as fact.


E-mail this story to a friend. Your name:

Your friend's e-mail:


tradeclips Jobsmake the next move in your journalism career Email bulletinsget latest news and jobs directly to your desktop Freelance indexsee our searchable list for freelance help CVadd your details to our journalism talent pool Dailywho owns it? who's the editor? Weeklysearch our vast database of local titles Your Paperwhat we've written about your newspaper Your Companywhat we've written about your company Blogsbest of the UK journalism blogs Resourcescontacts, web reviews, and terms unravelled Useful Linksour guide to the major industry organisations